It is currently Tue Feb 27, 2024 2:42 pm



Reply to topic  [ 47 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4
 All Time Africa All Stars 
Author Message

Joined: Sun Nov 25, 2012 1:31 pm
Posts: 405
AFRICA All Stars


Image



GOALKEEPERS:

:CAM: Joseph-Antoine BELL
:CAM: Thomas N'KONO
:ZIM: Bruce GROBBELAAR


DEFENDERS:

:ALG: Mustapha ZITOUNI
:CDR: Bwanga TSHIMEN
:CAM: Emmanuel KUNDÉ
:EGY: Ibrahim YOUSSEF
:NIG: Stephen KESHI
:CAM: Stephen TATAW
:NIG: Uche OKECHUKWU
:EGY: Hany RAMZY
:SOU: Lucas RADEBE
:MOR: Noureddine NAYBET
:CAM: Rigobert SONG


MIDFIELDERS:

:ALG: Mustapha DAHLEB
:CAM: Théophile ABEGA
:TUN: Tarak DHIAB
:ALG: Lakhdar BELLOUMI
:MOR: Mohammed TIMOUMI
:GHA: Abedi PELE
:NIG: Jay-Jay OKOCHA
:GHA: Michael ESSIEN


FORWARDS:

:GHA: Osei KOFI
:MAL: Salif KEÏTA
:CAM: Roger MILLA
:NIG: Segun ODEGBAMI
:EGY: Mahmmoud AL-KHATIB
:ALG: Rabah MADJER
:NIG: Rashidi YEKINI
:LIB: George WEAH
:COT: Didier DROGBA
:CAM: Samuel ETO'O



_____________________________________________________________


RESERVES:


GOALKEEPERS:

:GHA: Robert MENSAH
:MOR: Badou ZAKI
:EGY: Essam EL-HADARY


DEFENDERS:

:ALG: Marcel SALVA
:EGY: Rifaat EL-FANAGEELY
:GHA: John ESHUN
:SOU: Simon LEHOKO
:ALG: Noureddine KOURICHI
:ALG: Mahmoud GUENDOUZ
:CAM: André KANA-BIYIK
:NIG: Taribo WEST
:EGY: Wael GOMAA
:GHA: Samuel KUFFOUR
:CAM: LAUREN
:TUN: Hatem TRABELSI
:NIG: Celestine BABAYARO
:COT: Kolo TOURÉ
:MOR: Medhi BENATIA


MIDFIELDERS:

:EGY: Saleh SELIM
:ALG: Hacène LALMAS
:GHA: Ibrahim SUNDAY
:EGY: Ahmed HASSAN
:ALG: Ali BENCHEIKH
:NIG: Haruna ILERIKA
:LYB: Tarik EL-TAIB
:SOU: Patrick NTSOELENGOE
:MOR: Aziz BOUDERBALA
:COT: Youssouf FOFANA
:NIG: FINIDI George
:TUN: Zoubeir BAYA
:MOR: Mustapha HADJI
:NIG: Sunday OLISEH
:GHA: Stephen APPIAH
:COT: Yaya TOURÉ


FORWARDS:

:NIG: Teslim BALOGUN
:GUI: Chérif SOULEYMANE
:MOR: Ahmed FARAS
:COT: Laurent POKOU
:EGY: Hassan SHEHATA
:SEN: Jules BOCANDÉ
:ZAM Kalusha BWALYA
:ALG: Salah ASSAD
:ALG: Ahmed OUDJANI
:ALG: Rachid MEKHLOUFI
:CHA: Japhet N'DORAM
:GHA: Tony YEBOAH
:EGY: Hossam HASSAN
:CAM: Patrick M'BOMA
:NIG: Emmanuel AMUNIKE
:NIG: Daniel AMOKACHI
:NIG: Victor IKPEBA
:NIG: Nwankwo KANU
:SOU: Benni McCARTHY



THE BEST EVER XI:

---------------------------------N'Kono-------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------Keshi--------Zitouni-------Okechukwu----------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------Essien-------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------Abedi Pele-------------------
---------------------Belloumi----------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------Okocha------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------Weah----------------------------Eto'o----------------------
--------------------------------Drogba-------------------------------------


Sun Mar 10, 2013 3:02 pm
Profile
User avatar

Joined: Tue Jun 13, 2017 4:28 am
Posts: 4255
jcklein wrote:
I don't rate El-Hadary higher than Bell. His numbers doesn't necessarily translates how good he was. In fact, I wouldn't rate him higher than Grobbelaar or Zaki either.

I also think that he wasn't as good as N'Kono, Grobbelaar, Bell and Zaki. However, I don't find it right to create a team based solely on skills. This is just my opinion, of course.


Thu Nov 30, 2023 5:32 pm
Profile

Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2021 8:44 pm
Posts: 97
Interista93 wrote:
jcklein wrote:
I don't rate El-Hadary higher than Bell. His numbers doesn't necessarily translates how good he was. In fact, I wouldn't rate him higher than Grobbelaar or Zaki either.

I also think that he wasn't as good as N'Kono, Grobbelaar, Bell and Zaki. However, I don't find it right to create a team based solely on skills. This is just my opinion, of course.


I agree with that opinion too. I wouldn't put Thiago Silva in my Brazil All-Stars team even though he is probably the most skillfulled CB my country ever produced, but skill has a higher value in my view. You wound't put Dibu Martínez over Carrizo in an Argentina All-Stars squad, would you?

All players we're talking about here are legends. El-Hadary is much more praised for his longevity and titles rather than his skills. And don't get me wrong, I'm not saying he wasn't a great keeper. In fact, I believe he was nominated for the CAF Cup of Nations best team two or three times, but I don't think he was ever viewed as the very best African keeper even during his prime.


Thu Nov 30, 2023 11:41 pm
Profile
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Reply to topic   [ 47 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum

Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
Designed by ST Software for PTF.