It is currently Fri Mar 29, 2024 8:19 am



Reply to topic  [ 34 posts ]  Go to page 1, 2, 3  Next
 All Time Asia All Stars 
Author Message
User avatar

Joined: Tue Jun 13, 2017 4:28 am
Posts: 4289
All Time Asia All Stars

Image





GOALKEEPERS:

:SUA: Mohamed AL-DEAYEA
:IRAN: Nasser HEJAZI
:ISR: Ya'akov HODOROV


DEFENDERS:

:JAP: Makoto HASEBE
:SUC: HONG Myung-bo
:JAP: Masami IHARA
:SUC: KIM Ho-kon
:SUC: KIM Min-jae
:SUC: LEE Young-pyo
:JAP: Yūto NAGATOMO
:SUA: Saleh AL-NAIMA
:CHN: SUN JIhai
:SUA: Abdullah ZUBROMAWI


MIDFIELDERS:

:SUA: Fahad AL-BISHI
:JAP: Yasuhito ENDŌ
:JAP: Shinji KAGAWA
:IRAN: Mehdi MAHDAVIKIA
:JAP: Shunsuke NAKAMURA
:JAP: Hidetoshi NAKATA
:JAP: Yasuhiko OKUDERA
:SUC: PARK Ji-sung
:ISR: Giora SPIEGEL
:SUA: Youssef AL-THUNAYAN


FORWARDS:

:SUA: Majed ABDULLAH
:SUC: CHA Bum-kun
:IRAN: Ali DAEI
:JAP: Kunishige KAMAMOTO
:SUC: KIM Joo-sung
:CHN: LEE Wai Tong
:JAP: Kazuyoshi MIURA
:SUC: SON Heung-min
:ISR: Mordechai SPIEGLER


__________________________________________________


RESERVES:


GOALKEEPERS:

:ISR: Dudu AOUATE
:MLY: CHOW Chee Keong
:OMA: Ali AL-HABSI
:SUC: LEE Won-jae


DEFENDERS:

:ISR: Tal BEN HAIM
:IRAQ: Adnan DIRJAL
:CHN: FAN Zhiyi
:QAT: Abdelkarim HASSAN
:JAP: Takumi HORIIKE
:CHN: JIA Xiuquan
:KUW: Mahboub JUMA'A
:SUA: Mohammed AL-KHILAIWI
:SUC: KIM Jung-suk
:SUC: KIM Tae-young
:JAP: Yūji NAKAZAWA
:SUC: PARK Kyung-hoon
:IND: Jarnail SINGH
:MLY: SOH Chin Ann
:JAP: Atsuto UCHIDA


MIDFIELDERS:

:UAE: Omar ABDULRAHMAN
:IRAQ: Nashat AKRAM
:IRAN: Parviz GHELICHKHANI
:SUC: HA Seok-ju
:JAP: Keisuke HONDA
:IRAN: Ali KARIMI
:SUC: KIM Nam-il
:NOC: PAK Doo-ik
:NOC: PAK Sung-jin
:IRAN: Ali PARVIN
:UZB: Mirjalol QOSIMOV
:ISR: Haim REVIVO
:VIE: Đỗ THỚI VINH
:SUC: YOO Sang-chul
:CHN: ZHENG Zhi


FORWARDS:

:MYA: Suk BAHADUR
:IND: P.K. BANERJEE
:ISR: Yossi BENAYOUN
:CHT: CHEUNG Chi Doy
:SUA: Sami AL-JABER
:QAT: Mansour MUFTAH
:SUA: Saeed AL-OWAIRAN
:IRAQ: Ahmed RADHI
:INS: Andi RAMANG
:IRAQ: Hussein SAEED
:UZB: Maksim SHATSKIKH
:INS: Soetjipto SOENTORO
:UAE: Adnan AL-TALYANI
:IRAN: Mehdi TAREMI
:KUW: Jasem YACOUB





THE BEST EVER XI (by StuartBannigan)

Image

GK AL-DEAYEA
CB ZUBROMAWI
CB HONG M.B. ©
CB IHARA
RWB PARK J.S.
LWB LEE Y.P.
DMF HASEBE
AMF NAKAMURA
AMF AL-THUNAYAN
CF SON H.M.
CF CHA B.K.

Captain: Hong Myung-bo | Masami Ihara
Short free kick: Shunsuke Nakamura
Long free kick: Shunsuke Nakamura
Free kick 2: Youssef al-Thunayan | Lee Young-pyo
Right corner: Shunsuke Nakamura
Left corner: Shunsuke Nakamura
Penalty: Shunsuke Nakamura


Last edited by Interista93 on Wed Nov 15, 2023 1:11 am, edited 10 times in total.



Mon May 23, 2022 11:01 pm
Profile
User avatar

Joined: Tue Jun 13, 2017 4:28 am
Posts: 4289
Definitely not an easy task. If you have any suggestion or want explanations for some choices, you're welcome!

I know that we use to have two goalkeepers in the first squad but I didn't know who should be left out between Chow and Hejazi. Thangaraj was another valid choice.

Any help for the Best XI? It might end up being a mix of Japan and South Korea. :lol:


Mon May 23, 2022 11:05 pm
Profile

Joined: Fri Sep 15, 2017 8:43 pm
Posts: 1534
Well if you’re including Israeli players then I would definitely have included Hodorov and Spiegler in the first team. I also would have expected Lee Woon-Jae in this team. You have Majed Abdullah in both first team and reserves too, and Fahad Al-Bishi should be in the first team but isn’t even in the reserves, IMO he was even better than Al-Owairan. I don’t see a problem with including players from some of the “smaller” teams like Malaysia and India but the reality is that the teams like Saudi Arabia, Japan, South Korea and Iran are easily the most successful teams from Asia and have many players better than anyone from those smaller nations.


Mon May 23, 2022 11:36 pm
Profile
User avatar

Joined: Tue Jun 13, 2017 4:28 am
Posts: 4289
StuartBannigan wrote:
Well if you’re including Israeli players then I would definitely have included Hodorov and Spiegler in the first team. I also would have expected Lee Woon-Jae in this team. You have Majed Abdullah in both first team and reserves too, and Fahad Al-Bishi should be in the first team but isn’t even in the reserves, IMO he was even better than Al-Owairan. I don’t see a problem with including players from some of the “smaller” teams like Malaysia and India but the reality is that the teams like Saudi Arabia, Japan, South Korea and Iran are easily the most successful teams from Asia and have many players better than anyone from those smaller nations.


Abdullah in the reserves is a typo. Yeah, I tried to include players from more countries but I'm aware that this team may even include only players from China, Iran, Israel, Japan, Saudi Arabia and South Korea. In fact, the first team includes now only players from those countries plus Chow, Banerjee and Radhi. Of course, I'll make more changes as soon as I get more suggestions.


Tue May 24, 2022 12:28 am
Profile

Joined: Fri Sep 15, 2017 8:43 pm
Posts: 1534
I meant Mordechai Spiegler and not Giora Spiegel :D But Spiegel is a good choice for this team too.

BTW, what about players from Uzbekistan? Krasnitskiy and Qosimov would be good enough to be here and would play in the Asian federation for club and country if they were active today.

For the starting XI, maybe something like this:
Image

It's quite hard because there's no natural right back of starting XI quality (Sun Jihai was just an ok player, nothing more) so I went for 3 at the back with Lee and Park as WBs/SMFs and while Hasebe is probably the 3rd best CB he's also the best DMF here so I put him in midfield. I would have liked to fit Abdullah in but that's difficult too. I don't rate Nakata that highly tbh but I guess on "reputation" he should be here even though I think Kagawa was comfortably better than him at his peak.


Tue May 24, 2022 1:15 am
Profile
User avatar

Joined: Tue Jun 13, 2017 4:28 am
Posts: 4289
Mordechai hadn't come to mind and I guess I misread Spiegler in your previous comment, so I added Giora. :lol:
Who should Mordechai replace, Banerjee, Lee or Radhi? All them are widely regarded as the best player in their respective country but Banerjee ,may be the least popular choice.
Regarding the Uzbek players, I'd wait for more opinions. As we decided not to consider Australia, should Uzbekistan be considered European or Asian as it was part of Soviet Union?


Tue May 24, 2022 3:23 am
Profile

Joined: Wed Jun 26, 2013 9:38 pm
Posts: 2475
Dudu Aouate was one of the best La Liga goalkeepers of his time, performing consistently on top level for longer than any other Asian GK before him - and longer than most other Asian players in Europe. Tal Ben Haim should also be in reserves at least.
Other possible names would be Ali Parvin, Pak Doo Ik, Kim Tae-young, Kim Nam-il or Nashat Akram.
About the Uzbekistan debate: I find it hard to compare Uzbekistan with Australia since Australia is still the same country, they just purposely switched the conferederation. From Uzbekistan I'd just consider players from post indepence and those whose career spanned through both Soviet and independent era (for example Qosimov). Krasnitsky, Pshenichnikov or Abduraimov shouldn't be here IMO, since both their NT and club careers took place in European competitions.


Tue May 24, 2022 5:21 pm
Profile
User avatar

Joined: Mon Mar 11, 2013 5:46 pm
Posts: 174
Israel is a member of UEFA not AFC.....

_________________
[PS3 BLES 01708] The M Ace(ing) Classic Teams Optionfile (PES2013)

ImageImageImage


Wed May 25, 2022 6:11 am
Profile
User avatar

Joined: Tue Jun 13, 2017 4:28 am
Posts: 4289
M Ace wrote:
Israel is a member of UEFA not AFC.....


Israel was originally a member of AFC and had its peak as Asian national team as they won an Asian Cup in the 1960s.


Wed May 25, 2022 10:32 am
Profile
User avatar

Joined: Sat Nov 23, 2013 4:26 am
Posts: 3362
Location: Aragua De Barcelona, Venezuela
Nagatomo seems the better choice as RWB, as you don't rate Nakata that much, you could ditch him from starting eleven and put Park J-S as box-to-box midfielder.

I thought Daei was good enough, even to be the starting CF.


Fri May 27, 2022 3:53 am
Profile
User avatar

Joined: Tue Jun 13, 2017 4:28 am
Posts: 4289
El Capo wrote:
Nagatomo seems the better choice as RWB, as you don't rate Nakata that much, you could ditch him from starting eleven and put Park J-S as box-to-box midfielder.

I thought Daei was good enough, even to be the starting CF.


I have the same thought about Nagatomo. His Inter career was very good in my opinion. It was overshadowed by the fact that the team didn't win major trophies.


Fri May 27, 2022 11:32 am
Profile

Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2021 8:44 pm
Posts: 97
First, great job on that!

Second, I'm surprised Mokhtar Dahari and Javad Nekounam aren't listed even on reserves. Those two are on my first team.

Here's some more opinions:
1. I think Saleh Nu’eimeh is regarded as the best defender in Saudi Arábia history. He was the captain of the team that won the 1988 AFC Cup and was chosen for the team of the tournament. He should be ahead of Mohammed Al-Khilaiwi.
2. I would replace Fahad Al-Bishi with Javad Nekounam, and Ahmed Radhi with either Ali Daei or Mokhtar Dahari.
3. It makes more sense using Mehdi Mahdavikia as a RWB and move Park Ji-sung to the left on this formation.

My starting XI would be something like:
GK Mohamed AL-DEAYEA
RB Mehdi MAHDAVIKIA
CB Masami IHARA
CB HONG MYUNG-BO
LB Yasuhiko OKUDERA / Yuto NAGATOMO / LEE YOUNG-PYO
MF Makoto HASEBE
MF Hidetoshi NAKATA
MF PARK JI-SUNG
MF Shinji KAGAWA / Shunsuke NAKAMURA / Majed ABDULLAH (as FW)
FW CHA BUM-KUN
FW SON HEUNG-MIN


Mon Jun 27, 2022 5:00 am
Profile

Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2022 5:47 am
Posts: 12
nice job. i know It is difficult to access the information of Asian players. and this list has some problems.
ghelichkhani won 3 internatioal asian cup. more than any asian. and he is not in first team.
ali daei isn't in first team with 109 international goals. and also said al-owairan with that nice goal against belgium. same about and lee won jae. mukhtar dahari. paulino alcantra(if considered asian) and...

my list :


GOALKEEPERS

Mohamed AL-DEAYEA
LEE Won-jae
Nasser HEJAZI
(
additional option:
Ali AL-HABSI
CHOW Chee Keong
)




DEFENDERS:

FAN Zhiyi
Makoto HASEBE
HONG Myung-bo
Masami IHARA
LEE Young-pyo
Tal BEN HAIM
Yūto NAGATOMO
SUN JIhai
Abdelkarim HASSAN
Mohammed AL-KHILAIWI
(
additional option:
Yūji NAKAZAWA
Maya YOSHIDA
Abdullah ZUBROMAWI
Vitaliy DENISOV
)



MIDFIELDERS:

Shinji KAGAWA
Parviz GHELICHKHANI
Mehdi MAHDAVIKIA
Shunsuke NAKAMURA
Hidetoshi NAKATA
PARK Ji-sung
Haim REVIVO
Giora SPIEGEL
Ali PARVIN
KIM Joo-sung
Yossi BENAYOUN
(
additional option:
ZHENG Zhi
Ali KARIMI
Server DJEPAROV
Keisuke HONDA
Fahad AL-BISHI
Javad NEKOUNAM
Ali JABBARI
Yasuhiko OKUDERA
Karim BAGHERI
Valeri BROSHIN
)


FORWARDS:

Paulino ALCANTRA
SON Heung-min
Ali DAEI
Majed ABDULLAH
CHA Bum-kun
Kunishige KAMAMOTO
LEE Wai Tong
Kazuyoshi MIURA
(
additional option :
Mukhtar DAHARI
Sunil CHETRI
Ali MABKHOUT
Sami AL-JABER
Younis MAHMOUD
Sardar AZMOUN
Mehdi TAREMI
Ahmed RADHI
Shinji OKAZAKI
Omar AL-SOMAH
)

I hope I haven't forgotten anyone!!!! If I remember someone else, I will edit this


Tue Aug 09, 2022 3:06 pm
Profile
User avatar

Joined: Tue Jun 13, 2017 4:28 am
Posts: 4289
dariush99 wrote:
nice job. i know It is difficult to access the information of Asian players. and this list has some problems.
ghelichkhani won 3 internatioal asian cup. more than any asian. and he is not in first team.
ali daei isn't in first team with 109 international goals. and also said al-owairan with that nice goal against belgium. same about and lee won jae. mukhtar dahari. paulino alcantra(if considered asian) and...

my list :

Spoiler: show
GOALKEEPERS

Mohamed AL-DEAYEA
LEE Won-jae
Nasser HEJAZI
(
additional option:
Ali AL-HABSI
CHOW Chee Keong
)




DEFENDERS:

FAN Zhiyi
Makoto HASEBE
HONG Myung-bo
Masami IHARA
LEE Young-pyo
Tal BEN HAIM
Yūto NAGATOMO
SUN JIhai
Abdelkarim HASSAN
Mohammed AL-KHILAIWI
(
additional option:
Yūji NAKAZAWA
Maya YOSHIDA
Abdullah ZUBROMAWI
Vitaliy DENISOV
)



MIDFIELDERS:

Shinji KAGAWA
Parviz GHELICHKHANI
Mehdi MAHDAVIKIA
Shunsuke NAKAMURA
Hidetoshi NAKATA
PARK Ji-sung
Haim REVIVO
Giora SPIEGEL
Ali PARVIN
KIM Joo-sung
Yossi BENAYOUN
(
additional option:
ZHENG Zhi
Ali KARIMI
Server DJEPAROV
Keisuke HONDA
Fahad AL-BISHI
Javad NEKOUNAM
Ali JABBARI
Yasuhiko OKUDERA
Karim BAGHERI
Valeri BROSHIN
)


FORWARDS:

Paulino ALCANTRA
SON Heung-min
Ali DAEI
Majed ABDULLAH
CHA Bum-kun
Kunishige KAMAMOTO
LEE Wai Tong
Kazuyoshi MIURA
(
additional option :
Mukhtar DAHARI
Sunil CHETRI
Ali MABKHOUT
Sami AL-JABER
Younis MAHMOUD
Sardar AZMOUN
Mehdi TAREMI
Ahmed RADHI
Shinji OKAZAKI
Omar AL-SOMAH


I hope I haven't forgotten anyone!!!! If I remember someone else, I will edit this


I can agree with some choices here. I don't know about Paulino ALCÁNTARA. It's true that he capped for Philippines in 1917 but I'm not convinced. I'd like the opinion of other users too.


Tue Aug 09, 2022 3:30 pm
Profile
User avatar

Joined: Sat Nov 23, 2013 4:26 am
Posts: 3362
Location: Aragua De Barcelona, Venezuela
Not conviced of what?


Tue Aug 09, 2022 3:46 pm
Profile
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Reply to topic   [ 34 posts ]  Go to page 1, 2, 3  Next

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 15 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum

Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
Designed by ST Software for PTF.