Pes Miti del Calcio :: View topic

gurkenjoe93 wrote:

StuartBannigan wrote:

Since DimonSpa explained that he considers Yuri Voinov to be Russian and not Ukrainian, IMO he can replace Mostovoi in the first team here. Actually I'd use him in the starting XI over Andrey Starostin too but that decision is up to you.

So what? It would be new to me that Dimonspa's "standards" are now the ones to be followed here.
If Rudakov (born in Moscow but spent majority of his career in Ukraine and worked and lived their for the rest of his life) is apparently Ukrainian, then I don't get Voinov (who had basically exactly the same career and certainly wouldn't have stayed in Ukraine if he would have considered himself Russian) can't be considered as Ukrainian. Voinov is 100% Ukrainian for me, therefore I certainly won't add him here.

Author:	gurkenjoe93 [ Sun Mar 16, 2014 7:07 pm ]
Post subject:	Russia All Stars
RUSSIA ALL STARS The best ever Russian 23 Men Squad: *GOALKEEPERS:* Lev YASHIN Rinat DASAYEV *DEFENDERS:* Albert SHESTERNYOV Anatoli BASHASHKIN Yevgeniy LOVCHEV Viktor ONOPKO Yuri ZHIRKOV Vagiz KHIDIYATULLIN Aleksandr STAROSTIN *MIDFIELDERS:* Andrey STAROSTIN Valeri VORONIN Igor NETTO Valentin IVANOV Fyodor CHERENKOV Aleksandr MOSTOVOI Yuri GAVRILOV Fyodor SELIN *ATTACKERS:* Grigori FEDOTOV Igor CHISLENKO Eduard STRELTSOV Sergey ILYIN Vsevolod BOBROV Viktor PONEDELNIK _______________________________________________________________ *RESERVES:* *GOALKEEPERS:* Igor AKINFEEV Stanislav CHERCHESOV Dmitri KHARIN Vyacheslav MALAFEEV *DEFENDERS:* Aleksei BEREZUTSKI Konstantin KRYZHEVSKI Vasili BEREZUTSKI Boris KUZNETSOV Aleksandr ANYUKOV Leonid SOLOVYOV Anatoli MASLYONKIN Sergei IGNASHEVICH Vasiliy SOKOLOV Yuriy NIKIFOROV *MIDFIELDERS:* Alexey SMERTIN Ilia TSYMBALAR Konstantin ZYRYANOV IGOR DENISOV Igor SEMSHOV Diniyar BILYALETDINOV Dmitri KHOKLOV Valeri KARPIN Dmitri ALENICHEV Vasily RATS Viktor KOLOTOV Andrei KANCHELSKI Roman SHIROKOV Sergei SEMAK Yegor TITOV Igor SHALIMOV *ATTACKERS:* Roman PAVLYUCHENKO Mikhail BUTUSOV Andrei ARSHAVIN Konstantin BESKOV Oleg SALENKO Pavel POGREBNYAK Sergey SOLOVYOV Vladimir BESCHASTNYKH Dmitri RADCHENKO Sergey RODIONOV Aleksandr KERZHAKOV Vasili TROFIMOV Igor KOLYVANOV THE BEST EVER XI GK YASHIN CB SHESTERNYOV CB BASHASHKIN RB ALEKSANDR STAROSTIN LB LOVCHEV DMF ANDREY STAROSTIN CMF VORONIN CMF NETTO © SS IVANOV SS STRELTSOV CF FEDOTOV Captain: Igor Netto \| Andrey Starostin \| Albert Shesternyov Short Free Kick: Igor Netto Long Free Kick: Igor Netto Left Corner: Igor Netto Right Corner: Igor Netto Penalty: Grigori Fedotov

Author:	giomarino [ Sun Mar 16, 2014 8:13 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Russia All Stars
Maybe you can add Titov, Kolyvanov, Radchenko, Khokhlov to reserves...Also Tsimbalar and maybe 2 more defenders to reserves..

Author:	StuartBannigan [ Thu Sep 10, 2020 2:58 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Russia All Stars
Since DimonSpa explained that he considers Yuri Voinov to be Russian and not Ukrainian, IMO he can replace Mostovoi in the first team here. Actually I'd use him in the starting XI over Andrey Starostin too but that decision is up to you.

Author:	gurkenjoe93 [ Thu Sep 10, 2020 9:33 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Russia All Stars
StuartBannigan wrote: Since DimonSpa explained that he considers Yuri Voinov to be Russian and not Ukrainian, IMO he can replace Mostovoi in the first team here. Actually I'd use him in the starting XI over Andrey Starostin too but that decision is up to you. So what? It would be new to me that Dimonspa's "standards" are now the ones to be followed here. If Rudakov (born in Moscow but spent majority of his career in Ukraine and worked and lived their for the rest of his life) is apparently Ukrainian, then I don't get Voinov (who had basically exactly the same career and certainly wouldn't have stayed in Ukraine if he would have considered himself Russian) can't be considered as Ukrainian. Voinov is 100% Ukrainian for me, therefore I certainly won't add him here.

Author:	DimonSpa [ Wed Sep 30, 2020 12:08 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Russia All Stars
gurkenjoe93 wrote: StuartBannigan wrote: Since DimonSpa explained that he considers Yuri Voinov to be Russian and not Ukrainian, IMO he can replace Mostovoi in the first team here. Actually I'd use him in the starting XI over Andrey Starostin too but that decision is up to you. So what? It would be new to me that Dimonspa's "standards" are now the ones to be followed here. If Rudakov (born in Moscow but spent majority of his career in Ukraine and worked and lived their for the rest of his life) is apparently Ukrainian, then I don't get Voinov (who had basically exactly the same career and certainly wouldn't have stayed in Ukraine if he would have considered himself Russian) can't be considered as Ukrainian. Voinov is 100% Ukrainian for me, therefore I certainly won't add him here. Voinov was born in Russia, studied football in Russia, made his debut in the team of masters in Russia, made his debut for the national team in Russia, for several seasons he played at the highest level in Russia and only then in Ukraine. All that connects him with Ukraine is the Dynamo Kiev club and the fact that after the end of his career he remained in Ukraine. Rudakov was born in Russia, began his football education in Russia, but continued it in Ukraine, made his debut in the team of masters in Ukraine, made his debut for the national team in Ukraine, his only clubs at the highest level were in Ukraine. There is a difference between Voinov and Rudakov, which is why they are Russian and Ukrainian.

Pes Miti del Calcio http://www.pesmitidelcalcio.com/

Russia All Stars http://www.pesmitidelcalcio.com/viewtopic.php?f=82&t=5661	Page 1 of 1

Author:	MFR55 [ Wed Oct 07, 2020 11:16 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Russia All Stars
Anyone working on Igor Chislenko right now? some vids of him went up on youtube and vimeo rather recently, the news article his club published when his memorial plaque was done has some statements about his characteristics as a player might want to look into those things

Author:	James9408 [ Wed Apr 07, 2021 11:33 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Russia All Stars
Does anybody know where I can find stats for Bashashkin please?

Author:	jcklein [ Sun Sep 11, 2022 11:42 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Russia All Stars
Mario Fernandes should be at least on reserves. I don't think any other Russian RB did better than him at WC finals.

Page 1 of 1	All times are UTC
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group https://www.phpbb.com/