The topic has been brought on for a while. Therefore, I open a thread to post some practical examples since making stats for all the sets would take an immense amount of time. The sets are based off KONAMI originals. More details are included at the end of each post. I hope this helps.
GOALKEEPERSPES 2011 to PES 2013
Cláudio Taffarel
Attack: 30
Defence: 90
Balance: 83
Stamina: 61
Top Speed: 67
Acceleration: 68
Response: 97
Agility/Explosive Power: 73
Dribble Accuracy: 58
Dribble Speed: 50
Short Pass Accuracy: 50
Short Pass Speed: 58
Long Pass Accuracy: 66
Long Pass Speed: 74
Shot Accuracy: 43
Shot Power: 78
Shot Technique: 40 (removed in PES 2012)
Free Kick Accuracy/Place Kicking: 40
Swerve: 42
Heading: 48
Jump: 85
Technique/Ball Control: 60
Aggression: 68 (removed in PES 2012)
Mentality/Tenacity: 76
Goalkeeping Skills: 84
Team Work: 62
Injury Tolerance: A
Condition/Form: 5
Weak Foot Accuracy: 4
Weak Foot Frequency: 4
Consistency: 5 (removed in PES 6)
PES 2014 and PES 2015
Attacking Prowess: 42 (PES 2014) | 41 (PES 2015)
Ball Control: 60
Dribbling: 58
Low Pass: 50
Lofted Pass: 66
Finishing: 43
Place Kicking: 40
Swerve: 42
Header: 48
Defensive Prowess: 41
Ball Winning: 43
Kicking Power: 78
Speed: 67
Explosive Power: 73
Body Balance: 83
Jump: 85
Stamina: 61
Goalkeeping: 97
Saving: 84 (PES 2014) | 88 (PES 2015)
Form: 5
Injury Tolerance: 3
Weak Foot Use: 4 (PES 2014) | 2 (PES 2015)
Weak Foot Accuracy: 4 PES (2014) | 2 (PES 2015)
PES 2016 to PES 2019
Attacking Prowess: 41
Ball Control: 60
Dribbling: 58
Low Pass: 50
Lofted Pass: 63
Finishing: 43
Place/Set Piece Kicking: 40
Swerve/Curve: 42
Header: 45 (PES 2016) | 60 (PES 2017 to PES 2019)
Defensive Prowess: 51
Ball Winning: 42
Kicking Power: 75
Speed: 68
Explosive Power: 73
Body Control: 60
Body Balance/Physical Contact: 79
Jump: 79
Goalkeeping: 97
Catching: 88
Clearing: 90
Reflexes: 86
Coverage: 94
Stamina: 61
Weak Foot Use: 2
Weak Foot Accuracy: 2
Form/Condition: 5
Injury Tolerance: 3
PES 2020 and PES 2021
Offensive Awareness: 41
Ball Control: 60
Dribbling: 58
Tight Possession: 46 (while the value is close to that of the old Dribble Speed, I'm not sure if the two attributes are related)
Low Pass: 50
Lofted Pass: 63
Finishing: 43
Heading: 60
Plaece Kicking: 40
Curl: 42
Speed: 67
Acceleration: 73 (seemingly replaced Explosive Power)
Kicking Power: 75
Jump: 79
Physical Contact: 79
Balance: 60
Stamina: 61
Defensive Awareness: 51
Ball Winning: 42
Aggression: 52 (this one is a defensive attribute as opposed to the old Aggression that was offensive)
GK Awareness: 97
GK Catching: 88
GK Clearing: 90
GK Reflexes: 86
GK Reach: 94
NonDom Leg Usage: 2
NonDom Leg Precision: 2
Condition: 5
Injury Tolerance: 3
I came to conclusions after analysing a fair number of goalkeepers from various PES games.
● The
Ball Winning attribute introduced in PES 2014 doesn't work like the old
Response for goalkeepers. It's rarely high for goalkeepers and it's usually lower than
Defensive Prowess.
The highest
Ball Winning a goalkeeper has in PES 2014 is
46. Things changed in PES 2015 as many goalkeepers have a high value, although most of them seem random and probably a mistake by KONAMI.
In Pes 2016 though over 1300 goalkeepers have a value between
40 and
60, more than 100 have it between
61 and
78, and only Manuel Neuer has
89.
The ability is more balanced since PES 2017 as the maximum is
74 and only twelve, including Neuer, have it in PES 2017. However, I pretty much believe that most goalkeepers were mistakenly given a high value. Neuer has
41 in PES 2018 and 2019,
51 in PES 2020,
52 in PES 2021, while many random goalkeepers still have a high value (max
74 until PES 2020,
71 in PES 2021).
In conclusion, I'd always rate
Defensive Awareness higher than
Ball Winning regardless of what
Ball Winning value you decide to give a goalkeeper.
● The
Goalkeeping and
Saving attributes introduced in PES 2014 replaced the old
Response and
Goalkeeping Skills attributes respectively.
● The
Body Control/
Balance attribute introduced in PES 2017 helps a player maintaining the balance while avoiding tackles. Oddly enough, KONAMI gave higher values to random goalkeepers in comparison to the likes of Neuer and Ederson who are way more technically gifted. In my opinion, only goalkeepers like them deserve a
Body Control/
Balance value in the
70 area but not higher than
74.
● KONAMI introduced more key attributes for goalkeepers in PES 2016.
-
Goalkeeping/
GK Awareness is the keeper's ability to judge the situation and act in accordance. It can be compared to the old
Defence.
-
GK Catching is the keeper's ability to catch shots, even powerful ones. It can compared to the old
Goalkeeping Skills.
-
GK Reflexes determines how quickly a goalkeeper reacts. It can easily be compared to the old
Response.
-
GK Clearing is a more specific stat. It indicates how good a goalkeeper is at pushing the ball away to safe areas. Its meaning is between
GK Awareness and
GK Catching, although it seems closer to the latter. The value can be an average of
Defence and
Goalkeeping Skills unless a goalkeeper was specifically good or bad at clearing.
-
Coverage/
GK Reach determines how much goal the goalkeeper is able to cover when he reacts. Its meaning is between
GK Awareness and
GK Reflexes, although it seems closer to
GK Awareness. The value can be an average of
Defence and
Response unless the goalkeeper was specifically good or bad at covering his goal.
● The
Attack attribute that became
Attacking Prowess in PES 2014 and
Offensive Awareness in PES 2020 originally could go below
40 but no real goalkeeper had a value lower than
30. Since
40 became the minimum value, this attribute had to be adjusted. Considering only real goalkeepers, the equivalences are as following:
30 ->
40-
4131 ->
42-
4332-
33 ->
44-
4534-
35 ->
4636-
37 ->
47-
4838-
44 ->
4945-
49 ->
5050-
51 ->
51-
52● In general, the attributes
Dribbling Accuracy,
Short Pass Accuracy,
Long Pass Accuracy,
Shot Accuracy,
Free Kick Accuracy and
Swerve didn't get changes. No real goalkeeper used to have a value lower than
40 for any of these attributes and the minimum was rarely below
44. Therefore, KONAMI seemingly kept the same values in more recent games as well. Only certain more or less famous goalkeepers received boosts in these attributes, mostly since PES 2020.
● The
Heading attribute received a huge boost for goalkeepers, in some cases from PES 2015, otherwise from more recent games. In general, the boost is of about 15-20 points.
● The
Technique/
Ball Control attribute seems generally much higher for goalkeepers since PES 2015. Especially goalkeepers who had a value below
50 in old gen games often received a boost of at least 10 points in new games. The goalkeepers who used to have
50 or more either kept the same value or got a very small boost.