Since no one care about it

My Criteria:

32 Players Squad and 64 players's reserves in order to 'leave' no one behind.

All based on CL era, that's why no Alfredo, no Beckenbauer, no Phil Neal, no Baresi, etc.

Most Titles, Most Goals, Most Appearances and How Important the player was/is, it's the same criteria in the starting line up, just the most represensatives players..

PD: The only players IMO that are 90% replaceable are Zidane and Van Nistelrooy

Where's Costacurta? He was million times better than Pique, Abidal or Alves and won the cup three times, so he needs to be in first team here. And where the hell is Ryan Giggs? Two times UCL winner, one of the best wingers in UCL history but then Van Nistelrooy is there although he actually never even made it to the final..
Tbh those criterias aren't very good, UEFA CL All Stars should be the greatest players to play in this competition, not average players (i.e. Abidal, Dida and Valdes) who had the luck to be on the winning squad on some occasions..

Ruud out, Giggs in.

Costacurta in, instead of Abidal who played less and was less "determinant" than Billy.

Added some players to reserves..

Shouldn't be Van der Sar at least in reserves?

I thought that i've added him..Done..

Replaced Dida with Van Der Sar and added some others reserves players..

i should be here toni kross and modric and nacho or dani carvajar and paco gento, for the champions winning against borrusia dortmund, this forum needs a actual edit, toni kross and modric and carvajal or nacho and paco gento have 6 champions not messi or iniesta

Paco Gento has the exact amount of Champions League as all of us have: Zero. El Capo even explained that titles alone weren't the criteria here and yet you come up with Carvajal and Nacho. Let me guess: Scott Carson should replace Kahn? After all Scott has won two UCL while Kahn only won it once..
And since you think you can tell us what this forum actually needs: Certainly not users like you who just make nonsense posts..

I think Sergio Ramos, Modric & Kroos should be in.
Nesta, Morientes & Paulo Souza out.

This squad is already outdated, as we all can see that the record of the most titles (the author also made brackets to imply that those players are potential to raise their stats) now needs to be rewritten, then it is strange if none of them are in the main AS squad.

if we count throphies won half of the team should be about real players, Benzema deserves a spot too

None of my words saying that all the players with the most trophies should be in the first team. As the mod already explained Nacho and Carvajal have no doors to compete with the other colossuses in the current squad.

Carvajal, yes.

I don't think Carvajal is worse than Gary Neville. And Neville basically only won one title, he played 10 minutes total in the 07/08 season.

Lahm should be there above both anyway.