The fans loved him so much that some wrote rhymes about him, some of which have been preserved in the Cliftonville FC archive. An example from 1910 is quoted below:

"From the time the game commences, see him sleering through defences
you'll not style him an apprentice or a novice
He's no oaf however muddy, nor yet any kind of cuddy
But a lad who's made a study of his office”

The Cup Final was played at the famous Crystal Palace Exhibition Ground in Hyde Park in London on April 22nd 1911. During the Final Newcastle showed that they were not going to let go of the Cup without a fight, and they gave Bradford a right hard time of it from the first minute. City were well up for the battle, though, their midfield and defence was rock solid, and with Frank in such grand recent form their attack was always a threat to the Newcastle back line. However, the match was one in which neither team's forward line shone, and it finished 0-0 after extra-time.

That meant there had to be a Cup Final replay, which took place four days later on April 26th 1911 at Old Trafford in Manchester. The attendance for the replay was 66,646, which was the biggest ever crowd for a midweek match in England. Those spectators saw a match that was “an exhibition of hard, forthright tackling by both sides, in which the Bradford defence again performed heroically.” With Bradford under relentless pressure again from Newcastle, it seemed a long shot that Bradford would survive. But then, fifteen minutes into the game, Frank got forward down the right wing, went infield and found the space to play a perfect low pass into the box to put Bradford's centre-forward Spiers clear to score and make it 1-0. And they held on to the lead through to the final whistle. Bradford and Frank were FA Cup Champions!